Sponsor: Capital One
Location: Orlando, Florida
Stadium: Citrus Bowl
| Date Played | Winning Team | Losing Team | ||
| 1/1/1947 | Catawba | 31 | Maryville | 0 |
| 1/1/1948 | Catawba | 7 | Marshall | 0 |
| 1/1/1949 | Murray State | 21 | Sul Ross State | 21 |
| 1/2/1950 | St. Vincent | 7 | Emory & Henry | 6 |
| 1/1/1951 | Morris Harvey | 35 | Emory & Henry | 14 |
| 1/1/1952 | Stetson | 35 | Arkansas State | 20 |
| 1/1/1953 | East Texas State | 33 | Tennessee Tech | 0 |
| 1/1/1954 | Arkansas State | 7 | East Texas State | 7 |
| 1/1/1955 | Omaha | 7 | Eastern Kentucky | 6 |
| 1/2/1956 | Juniata | 6 | Missouri Valley | 6 |
| 1/1/1957 | West Texas | 20 | Southern Miss | 13 |
| 1/1/1958 | East Texas State | 10 | Southern Miss | 9 |
| 12/27/1958 | East Texas State | 26 | Missouri Valley | 7 |
| 1/1/1960 | Middle Tennessee | 21 | Presbyterian | 12 |
| 12/30/1960 | The Citadel | 27 | Tennessee Tech | 0 |
| 12/29/1961 | Lamar | 21 | Middle Tennessee | 14 |
| 12/22/1962 | Houston | 49 | Miami (Ohio) | 21 |
| 12/28/1963 | Western Kentucky | 27 | Coast Guard | 0 |
| 12/12/1964 | East Carolina | 14 | Massachusetts | 13 |
| 12/11/1965 | East Carolina | 31 | Maine | 0 |
| 12/10/1966 | Morgan State | 14 | West Chester | 6 |
| 12/16/1967 | UT Martin | 25 | West Chester | 8 |
| 12/27/1968 | Richmond | 49 | Ohio | 42 |
| 12/26/1969 | Toledo | 56 | Davidson | 33 |
| 12/28/1970 | Toledo | 40 | William & Mary | 12 |
| 12/28/1971 | Toledo | 28 | Richmond | 3 |
| 12/29/1972 | Tampa | 21 | Kent State | 18 |
| 12/22/1973 | Miami (Ohio) | 16 | Florida | 7 |
| 12/21/1974 | Miami (Ohio) | 21 | Georgia | 10 |
| 12/20/1975 | Miami (Ohio) | 20 | South Carolina | 7 |
| 12/18/1976 | Oklahoma State | 49 | BYU | 21 |
| 12/23/1977 | Florida State | 40 | Texas Tech | 17 |
| 12/23/1978 | NC State | 30 | Pittsburgh | 17 |
| 12/22/1979 | LSU | 34 | Wake Forest | 10 |
| 12/20/1980 | Florida | 35 | Maryland | 20 |
| 12/19/1981 | Missouri | 19 | Southern Miss | 17 |
| 12/18/1982 | Auburn | 33 | Boston College | 26 |
| 12/17/1983 | Tennessee | 30 | Maryland | 23 |
| 12/22/1984 | Florida State | 17 | Georgia | 17 |
| 12/28/1985 | Ohio State | 10 | BYU | 7 |
| 1/1/1987 | Auburn | 16 | USC | 7 |
| 1/1/1988 | Clemson | 35 | Penn State | 10 |
| 1/2/1989 | Clemson | 13 | Oklahoma | 6 |
| 1/1/1990 | Illinois | 31 | Virginia | 21 |
| 1/1/1991 | Georgia Tech | 45 | Nebraska | 21 |
| 1/1/1992 | California | 37 | Clemson | 13 |
| 1/1/1993 | Georgia | 21 | Ohio State | 14 |
| 1/1/1994 | Penn State | 31 | Tennessee | 13 |
| 1/2/1995 | Alabama | 24 | Ohio State | 17 |
| 1/1/1996 | Tennessee | 20 | Ohio State | 14 |
| 1/1/1997 | Tennessee | 48 | Northwestern | 28 |
| 1/1/1998 | Florida | 21 | Penn State | 6 |
| 1/1/1999 | Michigan | 45 | Arkansas | 31 |
| 1/1/2000 | Michigan State | 37 | Florida | 34 |
| 1/1/2001 | Michigan | 31 | Auburn | 28 |
| 1/1/2002 | Tennessee | 45 | Michigan | 17 |
| 1/1/2003 | Auburn | 13 | Penn State | 9 |
| 1/1/2004 | Georgia | 34 | Purdue | 27 (OT) |
| 1/1/2005 | Iowa | 30 | LSU | 25 |
| 1/2/2006 | Wisconsin | 24 | Auburn | 10 |
| 1/1/2007 | Wisconsin | 17 | Arkansas | 14 |
| 1/1/2008 | Michigan | 41 | Florida | 35 |
| 1/1/2009 | Georgia | 24 | Michigan State | 12 |
| 1/1/2010 | Penn State | 19 | LSU | 17 |
| 1/1/2011 | Alabama | 49 | Michigan State | 7 |
| 1/2/2012 | South Carolina | 30 | Nebraska | 13 |
